| |
RIGHTS-GUATEMALA: The Best-Kept
Secrets - the Military's
By Danilo Valladares
GUATEMALA (IPS) - Human rights groups are worried that
the declassification of military archives dating from
Guatemala's 1960-1996 civil war, which left more than
200,000 victims, by a special commission will not go far
enough in terms of clarifying the atrocities.
In March 2009, centre-left President Álvaro Colom
established the Military Archive Declassification
Commission, made up of three representatives of the
Defence Ministry, one delegate from the Presidential
Human Rights Commission, and three representatives of
presidential secretariats.
According to the agreement that gave rise to the
commission, its mandate is to sort out and file military
documents on national security affairs involving the
1954 to 1996 period. (In 1954, a coup d'etat organised
by the United States Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)
overthrew democratically elected President Jacobo Arbenz,
ushering in decades of military dictatorship.)
The agreement also gave Colom the authority to decide
not to declassify documents "that qualify as pertaining
to national security in the president's judgment."
Other countries in Latin America have also begun to take
steps to declassify military records to shed light on
human rights abuses committed during periods of
dictatorship.
In early January, Argentine President Cristina Fernández
ordered the military to declassify all documents related
to that country's 1976-1983 dictatorship, stating in a
decree that "such information cannot continue to be kept
inaccessible under the argument that it would threaten
national security."
Guatemala's Military Archive Declassification Commission
had a Jan. 12 deadline for completing its work, but
Colom extended it until June 2010.
In the meantime, human rights groups' doubts and
scepticism with regard to the possibility of real
progress are growing, because virtually nothing has come
out about the Commission's work.
They also point to precedents indicating that the
archives could be manipulated in order to hinder the
investigation of massacres and other human rights abuses
committed in the decades in question, and thus stand in
the way of eventual reparations for survivors and
victims' families and the possibility of bringing the
perpetrators to justice.
A National Reparations Programme was created in 2003 to
compensate survivors and the families of victims.
"My biggest concern is that the Commission won't receive
many records, or only some that are of little value in
clarifying the enormous atrocities committed," said
Andrew Hudson, manager of the Human Rights Defenders
Programme of Human Rights First, which is based in New
York and Washington.
"Although the Commission's work is confidential, as
legally established, the public has the right to know
what it has been up to. It should publish a brief report
on its activities," the activist told IPS.
In a letter addressed to President Colom,
representatives of Human Rights First, the Network in
Solidarity with the People of Guatemala (NISGUA), the
Guatemala Human Rights Commission/USA (GHRC), the
Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA), and the
National Security Archive (NSA) urged him to declassify
the military archives presented to him by the
Commission.
"The release of the military archives would be a
historic act of respect for human rights in Guatemala,"
the Dec. 21, 2009 letter says. "National security would
be strengthened by reaffirming a state of law and
bringing to justice those responsible for massive human
rights violations."
According to the 1999 report by the United
Nations-sponsored Historical Clarification Commission (CEH),
the 36-year civil war between government forces and
leftwing guerrillas claimed around 200,000 lives, mainly
rural indigenous villagers killed or forcibly abducted
by the state security forces and the local civilian
self-defence patrols (known as PACs) set up by the army.
The report blames 93 percent of the atrocities on
government forces and allied paramilitary death squads.
"The importance of the declassification of military
records lies in the fact that they contain information
on abuses committed by high-level military commanders
during the internal conflict and could be used as
evidence in trials of those responsible, to break with
the culture of impunity," said Hudson.
Another aspect that has given rise to concern among
civil society organisations is the role that the armed
forces are playing in the Military Archive
Declassification Commission. Not only do they have three
representatives on the Commission, but they coordinate
it themselves.
"It's like setting the fox to guard the hen house," said
Iduvina Hernández, head of the Association for the Study
and Promotion of Security in a Democracy (SEDEM).
The army should not decide which information to hand
over, but should limit its role to arranging the
transfer of the military documents, she told IPS, adding
that "until the army is completely overhauled, it will
continue protecting its performance during the
conflict."
Human rights groups asked the Commission to provide them
with a status report on its work, but the request was
turned down, said Hernández.
Legal rulings
So far, the army has only handed over a limited number
of documents, and only after it was forced to do so by a
court order.
In January 2007, an appeals court ruled that documents
were to be delivered to the Organismo Judicial (attached
to the Supreme Court) as evidence in several trials
involving massacres committed during the civil war.
In response to the order, in March 2009 the Defence
Ministry handed the courts the counterinsurgency plans
known as Victoria 82 and Firmeza 83, although the legal
ruling also required the armed forces to provide records
on two other counterinsurgency strategies: Operation
Ixil and Operation Sofía 82.
The National Security Archive's Guatemala Project
obtained the Operation Sofía 82 documents and presented
them to the Audiencia Nacional, Spain's highest criminal
court - which is trying a case brought by survivors and
victims' relatives - in early December 2009.
The declassified army records provide detailed orders
given by military and civilian authorities as part of an
army strategy carried out in the northwestern province
of Quiché to eliminate indigenous people - men, women
and children - seen as allies of the leftwing
guerrillas, as well as their housing, crops and
livestock, in the fight against "communism." The
documents include the names of commanders, operational
plans, directives, maps, telegrams and hand-written
patrol reports.
Former de facto president Gen. Efraín Ríos Montt
(1982-1983) and seven other top military and civilian
officials are facing genocide charges in the case,
originally filed in Spain in 1999 by Guatemalan Nobel
Peace Prize-winner Rigoberta Menchú and other survivors
of the atrocities committed during the armed conflict.
Ríos Montt's year and a half in power was the bloodiest
period of the civil war. Under his "scorched earth"
campaign, hundreds of indigenous villages were
completely wiped out and their residents massacred,
according to the Historical Clarification Commission.
Francisco Soto, a lawyer with the Centre for Legal
Action on Human Rights (CALDH), told IPS that the
Commission should comply with Colom's order to
declassify the military archives, and with the 2007
court ruling that stated that the documents did not
affect national security.
Soto lamented that "no visible progress" has been made
so far by the Commission. "We hoped for greater
political will with respect to opening up the archives
and contributing to the clarification of what happened
in Guatemala."
Although he said the handing over of some military
records as a result of the court order was an
achievement, the lawyer stressed that the work of the
Commission is "essential" because some counterinsurgency
plans have been mentioned, "but we don't know if the
government also had other ones."
Soto said that in order to clarify the crimes committed
during the war, it was also of vital importance to
declassify the National Police archives, which also
contain millions of documents.
Mario Polanco, the head of the Grupo de Apoyo Mutuo
(Mutual Support Group), a local human rights
organisation, told IPS that not only is there no
information on what the Commission is doing, but there
is also no indication of how its budget of 200,000
dollars is being used.
"The concern is that too much money is being earmarked
for a Commission that has provided no results and that
depends on the army's willingness to share information,"
he complained.
In his view, it will be legal rulings and pressure from
human rights groups that will bring about the release of
the rest of the army's counterinsurgency plans.
But if the Commission fulfills its role, its work could
play a crucial role in revealing the best-kept secrets:
the military's.
|
| |
|
|
|