 |
|
SPECIALREPORTS
| Saurday 04
September 2010 |
 |
|
 |
PORTUGAL
Prominent
Figures
Sentenced
in Child
Sex Ring
Scandal
By Mario
de
Queiroz
LISBON
(IPS) -
A trial
that
dragged
on for
six
years
amidst
public
outrage
ended
Friday
in
Portugal
with the
unexpected
sentencing
of
prominent
personalities,
found
guilty
in a
child
sex
abuse
scandal
that
shook
the
nation.
The sex
ring
scandal
involving
the Casa
Pía
state-run
children's
home in
Lisbon
broke in
late
2002,
when a
whistleblower
went to
the
press.
After a
police
investigation,
the case
went to
court in
November
2004,
and
became
the
longest,
most
costly
trial in
the
history
of
Portugal.
In the
66,100-page,
273-volume
ruling
with 588
appendices,
whose
summary
took all
day long
to read
out, the
three-judge
panel
convicted
six of
the
seven
defendants
of child
sex
abuse
committed
in the
1980s
and
1990s.
In Casa
Pía,
which is
home to
3,500
orphans
and
abandoned
or
troubled
children
from
around
the
country,
a
pedophile
ring
whose
clients
included
politicians,
diplomats,
doctors,
lawyers
and
journalists,
operated
in
secrecy
for two
decades.
The
youngsters,
mainly
boys,
were
driven
by the
Casa Pía
driver,
Carlos
Silvino,
to
different
locations,
where
they
were
abused
by the
six men
sentenced
Friday.
Since
the
start of
the
trial on
Nov. 25,
2004,
461
hearings
were
held in
different
courtrooms;
1,000
CDs, 352
DVDs,
1,000
tape
recordings
and 12
videos
were
listened
to or
watched;
and 981
people,
including
witnesses,
victims
and
defendants,
testified.
The most
well-known
defendants
are
Carlos
Cruz,
the
country's
most
popular
television
presenter
until
2002,
and
Jorge
Ritto,
who
retired
in 2002
after a
long and
distinguished
diplomatic
career
that
included
assignments
as
Portugal's
ambassador
to South
Africa
and to
the
United
Nations
Educational,
Scientific
and
Cultural
Organisation
(UNESCO)
in
Paris.
Silvino,
who was
at the
centre
of the
ring,
was
sentenced
to 18
years in
prison;
Cruz and
Dr. João
Ferreira
Diniz to
seven
years;
Manuel
Abrantes,
a former
assistant
director
of Casa
Pía, to
five
years
and nine
months;
Ritto,
to six
years
and
eight
months;
and
lawyer
Hugo
Marçal,
to six
years
and two
months.
Gertrudes
Nunes,
68,
whose
home in
Elvas,
13 km
from the
Spanish
border
on the
road
from
Lisbon
to
Madrid,
was used
by the
sex
ring,
was
acquitted.
Five of
the
convicted
men have
to pay
compensation
of
25,000
euros
(32,200
dollars)
to each
victim,
while
Silvino
has to
pay
15,000
euros
(19,325)
to each.
The
defendants
can
appeal
the
verdict,
which
the
three
judges
took
turns
reading
out.
As a
result,
the case
will
likely
continue
to drag
on for
years,
due to
the slow
pace of
justice
in
Portugal,
which
has
caused
public
outrage.
However,
the
initial
public
reactions
were
positive.
Fernanda
Aguiar,
who was
in the
crowd
outside
the
courthouse,
which
was
cordoned
off by
the
police
Friday,
told IPS
"this is
the
first
time the
judges
have
convicted
prominent
people,
which
could
indicate
that
things
are
starting
to
change."
Aguiar,
who
works at
a Lisbon
hotel,
added
that the
case was
especially
important
because
"it
involves
pedophilia,
which
includes
child
prostitution,
something
I see
every
day from
the
windows
of the
hotel,"
which
sits
across
from the
Eduardo
VII park
in
central
Lisbon.
The park
is a
notorious
gay
cruising
spot,
where
many of
the male
prostitutes
are
underage,
and most
of the
clients
who pick
them up
are over
40.
"That's
why
today,
when I
got off
work, I
came
over
here to
see what
would
happen,"
she
said. "I
hope
this
serves
as an
example
for the
men who
cruise
by the
park in
their
fancy
cars
picking
up boys
who are
poor."
Child
sex
abuse is
a
problem
throughout
the
European
Union,
which
began in
2004 to
expand
and
strengthen
its
mechanisms
for
tracking
down
missing
children
and
combating
child
sexual
exploitation,
which is
especially
an issue
in the
bloc's
poorest
countries.
That
year,
the
European
Commission,
the EU
executive
organ,
released
a study
on the
practical
application
of the
Interpol's
international
child
sexual
exploitation
database.
Without
questioning
the
police
measures
taken,
the
European
Communist
Party
says
child
sexual
exploitation
is
inextricably
linked
to
problems
like
discrimination
and
poverty
-- in
other
words,
the
problem
can only
be
solved
"when
that
situation
is also
resolved,
independently
of the
necessary
law
enforcement
action."
In March
2009,
the EU
formed
an
alliance
between
companies
and
police
forces,
with the
aim of
exchanging
private
financial
information
and
identifying
criminals
involved
in the
sale of
online
child
porn.
The
initiative
to fight
child
porn web
sites
and
protect
victims
involves
the EU,
credit
card
companies,
internet
providers
and
police
forces.
Companies
that
have
signed
on
include
MasterCard,
Microsoft,
PayPal
and Visa
Europe.
In
March,
Cecilia
Malmström,
EU
Commissioner
for Home
Affairs,
presented
proposals
to
harmonise
the
prosecution
of child
sex
abuse
and
human
trafficking,
and to
step up
the
fight
against
online
child
porn by
including
new
forms of
abuse,
such as
luring
children
over the
internet,
having
children
pose
sexually
in front
of
webcams,
or
watching
child
porn
without
downloading.
In
response
to
criticism,
she said
"Child
pornography
is not
about
freedom
of
expression.
It is a
horrendous
crime.
It is
not
about
circulating
an
opinion."
Worldwide,
reports
of
online
child
porn
increased
149
percent
between
2003 and
2008,
according
to a
2009
report
by an
Italian
NGO,
Telefono
Arcobaleno,
which
monitors
the
internet
on a
daily
basis to
detect
pedophile
activity
and warn
web
operators
and the
authorities.
Europe
is the
region
with the
most
online,
and
fastest-growing,
child
porn
activity.
From
2003 to
2008,
child
porn
material
grew 406
percent
on
European
web
servers.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|