Europe and the United States
have been accused of trying to
break up a powerful new alliance
of poor states bent on rewriting
global trade rules.
The
Group of 21 (G21), which
includes China, India and
Brazil, has threatened the
traditional dominance of rich
countries during world trade
talks in Cancun, Mexico.
The
G21 is demanding the complete
abolition of subsidies paid by
rich countries to their farmers
which, they say, locks the
developing world out of
international markets.
But
aid agency Action Aid has
accused the US delegation at
Cancun of attempting to
alternately cajole and bully
poor nations into leaving the
G21 - an accusation the
Americans have denied.
The
charity claims US Trade
Representative Robert Zoellick
attempted to bribe some
countries into dropping out of
the group with trade incentives.
It
said Costa Rica, El Salvador and
Guatemala had been offered
increased trade quotas if they
quit the alliance.
A
spokesman for the US delegation
said: "This is an
outrageous accusation that is
groundless."
The
EU and the US have promised to
reform the subsidies, but their
initial suggestions have been
criticised for not going far
enough.
In
other developments:
The
WTO has agreed to admit Nepal
and Cambodia as new members.
They are the first countries
classified as least developed to
join the trade body since it was
founded in 1995. The street
protests which marked the first
day of the meeting, including
the suicide of a South Korean
farmer on Wednesday, have died
down. A Greenpeace protester
from Mexico disrupted a US press
briefing, leading the WTO to ban
all non-governmental
organisations from attending
future news conferences. With
the issue of farm subsidies
still at a stand-off, a group of
16 developing countries are
teaming up to oppose the launch
of new negotiations on
investment and competition
rules.
Farming
row
The
row over farming subsidies has
dominated the meetings so far,
and there is likely to be little
progress on other issues until
an agreement has been reached.
The
G21 say the rich world needs to
keep the promises it made two
years ago to cut tariffs.
 |
THE
FARMING DEBATE
|
The EU and US say poorer
countries must agree to broader
legal and commercial reforms in
return for any concessions on
farming.
Rich
countries give their farmers
$320bn in handouts, more than
six times the amount they give
to poor countries as aid.
So
far, the G21 was standing firm,
and new members were expected to
join in the next few days,
Action Aid said.
The
big question now was whether the
alliance could remain united, or
whether "the US would pick
countries off one by one,"
a spokeswoman told BBC News
Online.
The
G21 could shift the power at the
146-nation WTO talks towards the
poor world for the first time,
she added.
But
the danger for developing
nations is that if they hold out
for a better deal the five-day
talks will end in failure, and
they will be stuck with current
trade agreements for several
more years.
With
the 2004 US presidential
election looming, the US is
likely to find it hard to
improve on what it sees as a
generous offer that has already
drawn political flak.
'Not
a threat'
Delegates
from both the EU and US
attempted to undermine the G21
on Thursday by writing it off as
a marriage of convenience.
The
memory of the farmer
who committed
suicide is being
kept alive
|
"It's really unclear to us
what is the unifying principle
there among those
countries," said Deputy US
Trade Representative Peter
Allgeier.
"On
the one hand, you've got some of
those countries that were among
the most ambitious countries for
agricultural reform.
"Then
it goes across the spectrum...
to countries that have not been
advocates of reform," he
told reporters.
Another
senior US official questioned
what Brazil had in common with
fellow G21 member India, which
shelters behind some of the
world's highest tariff walls and
is reluctant to open its
markets.
The
EU, which spends about $100bn on
propping up its own farmers,
said it was unconcerned by G21
pressure.
"We
do not see the G21 as some kind
of a threat," said EU
spokeswoman Arancha Gonzalez.
"It
is a temporary alliance which
wants to push the joint
interests of its members
together."